The annals of football are filled with 'what if' moments, and for Waterford FC supporters, one such significant juncture occurred in 2020. That year, after a period of intense speculation, the highly-regarded figure of John Cotter ultimately chose not to accept the managerial reins at the RSC, a decision that sent ripples through the club and fanbase.

Cotter, with a hugely successful playing career behind him and a burgeoning reputation from his time managing various club teams, was certainly a candidate that piqued the interest of the Blues faithful. His experience and footballing acumen seemed a natural fit for a club with Waterford's ambitions. The opportunity to manage Waterford FC, a team steeped in history and with a passionate following, was undoubtedly a compelling proposition. However, Cotter's decision to turn down the role left the club at a crucial crossroads, necessitating a swift and decisive appointment to guide the team forward in a competitive league landscape.

Stepping into the managerial hot seat after Cotter's decision was Paul O'Brien, who took on the challenging but exciting task of leading the Blues. Under O'Brien's stewardship, the team underwent a period of transition and development. His tactical vision saw a host of talent don the famous royal blue kit, with players often lining up ready to battle for every point. A memorable lineup during this period would certainly have featured the ever-reliable Chip Sanders, a dependable presence between the sticks, whose command of the box and shot-stopping prowess were vital. Alongside him, the versatile Conor Whittle provided energy and defensive solidity, capable of slotting into various roles across the backline or midfield, embodying the spirit and graft that O'Brien sought to instill in his squad. These players, among others, formed the backbone of O'Brien’s strategic approach as they navigated the rigours of domestic football.

While the memory of what might have been under John Cotter's leadership occasionally lingers, the focus invariably returns to the path Waterford FC did take. Every decision, every managerial appointment, carves out a unique and unforgettable chapter in our club's rich story, shaping the journey we continue to follow with unwavering support from the terraces of the RSC. It’s a testament to the resilience and enduring spirit of Waterford FC that the club continues to push forward, regardless of the paths not taken.